I used Marmalead for 6 months before switching to Insight Agent. The difference in data quality was immediately obvious - no more suspicious search volume numbers. Plus, I can now research Amazon products AND Etsy in one place. Should have switched sooner!
Marmalead vs Insight Agent: Which Etsy Tool is Better in 2026?
Comparing Marmalead and Insight Agent for your Etsy keyword research? This detailed 2026 comparison covers data accuracy, pricing, multi-platform capabilities, and whether Marmalead is worth it for sellers who want to grow beyond Etsy.
Quick Verdict: If you only sell on Etsy and prioritize simplicity, Marmalead may work. However, if you need accurate data (not Pinterest estimates), plan to expand to Amazon/POD/KDP, or want better value, Insight Agent is the superior choice.
Real Etsy sales data vs Pinterest-based estimatesMulti-platform (Etsy + Amazon + POD + KDP) vs Etsy-onlyFree tier available vs $19/month minimumData updated 2x daily vs standard updatesVerified accuracy vs documented accuracy concerns
No credit card required. No risk. Cancel anytime (with access through billing period).
JB
JA
SR
insightagent.app/etsy-trends/
What is Marmalead?
Marmalead is an Etsy SEO tool that helps sellers find keywords using Pinterest trend data to estimate Etsy search volume. Launched as one of the early Etsy keyword research tools, it offers features like the "Storm" brainstorming tool, seasonal trend tracking, and competition visualization.
Marmalead Key Facts
- Price:$19/month (single plan, Etsy only)
- Data Source:Pinterest API trends (not direct Etsy data)
- Best For:Beginner Etsy sellers wanting simple keyword research
- Limitations:Etsy-only, documented accuracy concerns, no data exports
- Access Policy:Immediate loss of access upon cancellation (even mid-billing cycle)
The Core Problem
Etsy doesn't share proprietary search data with third-party tools. Any tool claiming exact Etsy search volumes is using estimates. The question is: which estimation method is more reliable? Marmalead uses Pinterest trend correlation, while Insight Agent tracks actual Etsy sales data.
Why Sellers Search for Marmalead Alternatives
Sellers looking for Marmalead alternatives typically cite these concerns:
📊
Questionable Data Accuracy
The Pinterest Problem: Marmalead uses Pinterest trends to estimate Etsy search volume - a methodology with documented issues. Real Example: The keyword "summer hat" showed only 35 searches for July-August (peak summer season). This is highly suspicious and raises concerns about the reliability of all estimates.
🚫
Etsy-Only Limitation
Marmalead supports Etsy exclusively - no Amazon product research, no POD trend tracking, no KDP book niche research. If you want to diversify income streams, you need additional tools ($10-30/month each). Multi-Platform Alternative: Insight Agent includes Etsy + Amazon + POD + KDP in one subscription.
💰
Expensive for Limited Features
At $19/month ($228/year) for an Etsy-only tool with accuracy concerns, Marmalead is more expensive than multi-platform alternatives with better data accuracy. What You Don't Get: No data exports, No AI optimization assistant, No browser extension, No email marketing features, No multi-platform research.
⏱️
Immediate Access Loss on Cancellation
Unlike standard subscription services, Marmalead revokes ALL access immediately when you cancel - even if you're mid-billing cycle. This aggressive policy frustrates sellers who want to downgrade or take a break.
🔍
No Real Etsy Data
Critical Insight: Etsy doesn't share proprietary search metrics with third parties. Marmalead's Pinterest correlation is an indirect estimation method. Better Approach: Insight Agent tracks real Etsy sales data (verifiable marketplace metrics) instead of Pinterest signals, providing more reliable insights into what actually sells.
⚠️
The Core Problem with Marmalead
Etsy doesn't share proprietary search data with third-party tools. Any tool claiming exact Etsy search volumes is using estimates. The question is: which estimation method is more reliable?
Marmalead uses Pinterest trend correlation, while Insight Agent tracks actual Etsy sales data.
Why It Matters: Basing your product decisions on inaccurate data can lead to wasted time creating items nobody is searching for.
Marmalead vs Insight Agent: Complete Feature Comparison
See how the two Etsy research tools compare across key features and capabilities
| Feature | Marmalead | Insight Agent |
|---|---|---|
| Platform Support | Etsy only | Etsy + Amazon + POD + KDP + Digital Products |
| Data Type | Pinterest-based estimates | Real Etsy sales data |
| Data Accuracy | Questionable (Pinterest correlation) | Verified, updated twice daily |
| Update Frequency | Standard updates | Twice daily (Etsy trends) |
| Keyword Research | Storm tool, brainstorming | Multi-platform keyword research |
| Trends Explorer | Seasonal trends (limited) | Comprehensive trends (all platforms) |
| Shop Analyzer | Competition visualization | Deep analytics + 30-day sales |
| AI Optimization | None | Advanced DSPy AI agents |
| Browser Extension | None | Full responsive web app |
| Data Exports | None | Available |
| Access After Cancel | Immediate loss | Standard billing period |
| Starting Price | $19/month (single plan) | Free tier + multiple plans |
Three-Way Comparison: Marmalead vs eRank vs Everbee vs Insight Agent
Not sure which Etsy keyword tool is right for you? Here's how all major options compare:
| Feature | Marmalead | eRank | Everbee | Insight Agent |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pricing | $19/mo | $0-29.99/mo | $0-99/mo | Free + Paid |
| Data Type | Pinterest estimates | Estimated search volume | Estimated data | Real sales data |
| Platforms | Etsy only | Etsy only | Etsy only | Etsy + Amazon + POD + KDP |
| Free Tier | No | Yes (limited) | Yes (limited) | Yes (core features) |
| Accuracy | Questionable | Estimated | Estimated | Verified, 2x daily |
| Best Feature | Storm brainstorming | Rank checker | Product analytics | Multi-platform + real data |
| Biggest Weakness | Pinterest data | Etsy-only | Expensive pro tier | Newer brand |
Key Insight
All three competitors (Marmalead, eRank, Everbee) are limited to Etsy and use estimated data. Only Insight Agent offers real sales tracking + multi-platform support.
What Makes Insight Agent Different from Marmalead
Real sales data, multi-platform coverage, and better value that Marmalead can't match
✅
Real Sales Data (Not Pinterest Estimates)
The Accuracy Advantage: We track actual Etsy sales from verified listings, updated twice daily. No Pinterest correlations. No suspicious estimates like "35 searches for summer hat in July." How It Works: Direct monitoring of Etsy marketplace listings, Sales tracking from real product performance, Twice-daily data updates for current trends, Verifiable numbers you can cross-check.
- Direct Etsy marketplace monitoring
- Real product performance tracking
- Updated twice daily
- Verifiable cross-checkable data
- No Pinterest correlation methods
🌐
Multi-Platform Coverage Beyond Etsy
Diversify Your Income: Research trends across multiple platforms from one dashboard. Cost Savings: Replaces Marmalead (Etsy) + Helium 10 (Amazon) + Book Bolt (KDP) = $50-100/month in multiple subscriptions.
- Etsy: Keyword research, sales tracking, trend analysis
- Amazon: Product research, BSR tracking, niche discovery
- POD Platforms: Printful, Printify, Redbubble trend tracking
- KDP: Book niche research, keyword optimization
- Digital Products: Downloadable product trend analysis
💵
Better Value for Your Money
Marmalead Annual: $190/year (Etsy only, Pinterest estimates, questionable accuracy). Insight Agent: Similar or lower price with multi-platform coverage + real sales data.
- Free tier with core features (no credit card)
- No immediate access loss on cancellation
- Data export capabilities for your records
- AI-powered optimization suggestions
- Multi-platform research included
🎯
Advanced Features Marmalead Doesn't Offer
AI Optimization: DSPy-powered agents help optimize listings, find opportunities, and generate ideas. Data Exports: Download your research for client reports, business planning, or offline analysis. Better Search Filtering: Find low-competition, high-demand niches with advanced filters Marmalead lacks.
- AI-powered listing optimization
- Full data export capabilities
- Advanced filtering for niche discovery
- Real-time marketplace accuracy
- No waiting for Pinterest updates
Is Marmalead Worth It in 2026?
Short Answer
Marmalead is only worth it if you're a beginner Etsy-only seller who values simplicity over accuracy and doesn't plan to expand to other platforms.
For Most Sellers, Marmalead Is NOT Worth It Because:
1
Data Accuracy Issues
Pinterest-based estimates have documented problems (e.g., "summer hat" showing 35 searches in July-August)
2
Etsy-Only Limitation
No support for Amazon, POD, or KDP expansion
3
Poor Value
$19/month for limited features vs multi-platform alternatives at similar prices
4
Harsh Cancellation
Immediate access loss, even mid-billing cycle
5
No Advanced Features
Missing data exports, AI optimization, browser extensions
6
Better Alternatives
Tools with real sales data and multi-platform support available
When Marmalead MIGHT Be Worth It:
- You're brand new to Etsy and overwhelmed by complex tools
- You absolutely will never sell on Amazon, POD, or KDP
- You prefer simple interfaces over comprehensive features
- You don't mind estimated data (Pinterest correlation)
Better Alternative for Serious Sellers
Choose a tool with real sales data and multi-platform support to future-proof your business.
Try Insight Agent FreePricing Comparison: Marmalead vs Insight Agent
Better value, more platforms, and real data for similar or lower price than Marmalead
Marmalead
$19/mo
- • Etsy ONLY
- • Pinterest estimates
- • Questionable accuracy
- • No data exports
Marmalead Annual
$15.83/mo
- • Still Etsy only
- • Still estimates
- • Lose access on cancel
- • Limited features
Insight Agent Starter
Competitive
- • Etsy + Amazon + POD + KDP
- • Real sales data
- • Better accuracy
- • More features
Insight Agent Pro
Best Value
- • All platforms
- • AI optimization
- • Verified data
- • Export capabilities
Cost-Benefit Analysis
Marmalead: $19/month = $19 per platform (Etsy only)
Insight Agent: Similar pricing = $4-5 per platform (Etsy + Amazon + POD + KDP + Digital)
ROI Comparison: Marmalead - Limited to Etsy income. Insight Agent - Diversify across 4+ platforms = more income streams, better risk management.
How to Switch from Marmalead to Insight Agent
Switching is risk-free with our free tier. Compare data accuracy before committing.
1
Sign Up for Free (No Credit Card Required)
Create your free Insight Agent account at app.insightagent.app/etsy-trends. What You Get Free: Real Etsy sales data access, Basic keyword research, Shop analyzer, Multi-platform browsing.
2
Compare Data Accuracy
Side-by-Side Test: 1) Pick 5 keywords you researched in Marmalead, 2) Search the same keywords in Insight Agent, 3) Compare our real sales data with Marmalead's Pinterest estimates, 4) Notice the accuracy difference. Example: Search "summer hat" and see realistic seasonal data instead of suspicious "35 searches in July-August" estimates.
3
Explore Multi-Platform Features
Beyond Etsy: Try researching Amazon products, POD trends, or KDP niches - platforms Marmalead doesn't support. Discover Opportunities: See if your Etsy products could also work on Amazon, Redbubble, or as digital downloads.
Important: Marmalead Cancellation Warning
Warning: Marmalead revokes access immediately upon cancellation, even if you're mid-billing cycle. Wait until the end of your billing period to maximize value.
Better Approach with Insight Agent: We provide access through the end of your billing period when you cancel.
No risk. Free tier available. See real data vs Pinterest estimates.
Get Started FreeWhat Sellers Say About Switching from Marmalead
Real results from real sellers
The Pinterest-based estimates in Marmalead never made sense to me. When I found Insight Agent's real sales data, everything clicked. I'm finding better niches and making more confident product decisions.
Marmalead was costing me $19/month for just Etsy. Insight Agent costs about the same but includes Amazon, KDP, and POD research. The ROI is incredible - I've expanded to 3 platforms now.
Loading case study...
Frequently Asked Questions: Marmalead vs Insight Agent
Everything you need to know about switching from Marmalead
The biggest difference is data accuracy. Marmalead uses Pinterest trends to estimate Etsy search volume (documented as unreliable), while Insight Agent tracks real Etsy sales data verified and updated twice daily. Additionally, Insight Agent supports multiple platforms (Etsy + Amazon + POD + KDP) while Marmalead is Etsy-only.
No. We track real Etsy sales data directly from actual listings. We don't rely on Pinterest trends or any indirect correlation methods. Our data comes from verified sales tracking across the Etsy marketplace, updated twice daily.
Our Etsy data is based on real sales tracking from actual listings, not estimates or projections. We update trends twice daily to ensure current accuracy. Unlike tools that use Pinterest trends or search volume estimates, we track verifiable sales data. When you see a trend in Insight Agent, it's based on actual marketplace performance.
Yes! Unlike Marmalead which is Etsy-only, Insight Agent includes full Amazon product research capabilities. You get keyword research, product trends, shop analytics, and BSR tracking for Amazon - plus Etsy, POD platforms, and KDP. Many sellers choose Insight Agent specifically because it covers both Etsy AND Amazon.
Our free tier includes access to Etsy trends with real sales data, basic keyword research, and shop analyzer features. You can explore the platform and compare our data accuracy with Marmalead's estimates before upgrading. Free users can browse trends, view top-performing items, and verify the accuracy difference firsthand.
Yes. Insight Agent is equally beginner-friendly but with better data accuracy. Both tools have intuitive interfaces, but Insight Agent gives beginners real sales data to learn from (not Pinterest estimates that might mislead). Plus, our free tier lets beginners start without financial risk - Marmalead requires $19/month minimum.
Absolutely. Marmalead only covers Etsy with questionable data accuracy. Insight Agent replaces: Marmalead (Etsy), Helium 10/Jungle Scout (Amazon), Book Bolt (KDP), and POD research tools. Cost Savings: Save $50-100/month by consolidating tool subscriptions. One platform for all your marketplace research needs.
We track real sales data, which is more valuable than search volume estimates. Search volume can be misleading (as Marmalead's "summer hat" = 35 searches example shows). Sales data tells you what actually sells, not just what people search for. Our twice-daily updates show real marketplace performance with verifiable numbers.
Unlike Marmalead where you lose ALL access immediately upon cancellation (even if your billing period hasn't ended), Insight Agent follows standard subscription practices. You retain access through the end of your current billing period. We also have a free tier, so you can downgrade instead of canceling completely.
We offer a full responsive web application that works on desktop, tablet, and mobile. While we don't currently have a dedicated browser extension like some tools, our web app provides comprehensive research capabilities without needing to install additional software.
Yes! Unlike Marmalead which doesn't offer data exports, Insight Agent allows you to export your research data, trends, keywords, and analytics. This is especially valuable for client work, business reporting, or integrating with your own systems. Export capabilities are available on paid plans.
Insight Agent's Etsy tag generator uses real sales data to suggest tags based on what actually performs in the marketplace. Marmalead's suggestions are based on Pinterest trend estimates. Our approach gives you tags backed by actual sales performance, not indirect correlation data.
Related Resources
Compare All Etsy Tools
Feature-Specific Guides
Looking for more information? Explore our comprehensive guides to find the perfect Etsy research tool for your business.
Ready to Try Real Etsy Sales Data?
Join 201,000+ sellers who use Insight Agent for: Real Etsy sales data (not Pinterest estimates), Multi-platform coverage (Etsy + Amazon + POD + KDP), Better value than Etsy-only tools, Free tier available - no credit card required. See the Accuracy Difference for Yourself.