The Printify ProductsActually Selling on Etsy in 2026
Printify makes it easy to start selling—but choosing the right products? That's where most sellers get stuck.
With 850+ products in Printify's catalog and thousands of design possibilities, you could spend months testing before finding what works. Or you could skip straight to what's already proven.
💡Quick Takeaways
- ✓Home decor dominates Printify sales — Throw pillows, blankets, and canvas prints lead revenue
- ✓Target 35-50% profit margins — Sustainable pricing after Printify costs and Etsy fees
- ✓Personalization multiplies value — Custom products command 30-50% higher prices
- ✓Specific niches beat generic — "Golden Retriever Mom" outsells "Dog Mom" by 3:1
- ✓Premium products = better margins — Metal prints and DTG hoodies outperform basics
Why Printify Specifically?
Before diving into products, here's why Printify stands out for Etsy sellers
Largest product catalog
850+ products across 90+ categories (vs Printful's 350+)
Competitive pricing
Often 10-25% cheaper than Printful on comparable items
Print Provider network
90+ global facilities = faster shipping, lower costs
Premium catalog
Access to DTG, embroidery, all-over print, sublimation options
Etsy integration
Direct sync makes listing management seamless
The tradeoff: More manual quality control needed since providers vary. Always order samples before scaling.
The Top 10 Best Selling Printify Products on Etsy (2026)
Ranked by revenue potential and profit margins
Throw Pillows
The Consistent Performer
Why they sell: Home decor staple with year-round demand. Easy to personalize, gift-friendly, and buyers often purchase 2-4 at once.
💰Profit Breakdown
🎯Winning Niches
- •Personalized family names — "The Johnsons Est. [Year]"
- •Pet portraits — Upload photo, custom illustration
- •Funny sayings — Home/lifestyle humor
- •Boho/minimalist designs — Geometric patterns, line art
- •Seasonal/holiday — Thanksgiving, Christmas, spring florals
Average order value: $35-45 per pillow, often $70-120 when buying sets
Pro tip: Offer "set of 2" discounts to increase AOV. Price single at $35, two for $60, four for $110.
Mugs (11oz and 15oz)
The Volume King
Why they sell: Ultimate impulse buy at $15-22 price point. Perfect for gifts, personal use, and collections. Buyers return for multiple purchases.
💰Profit Breakdown
🎯Winning Niches
- •Occupation/profession — "World's Best Teacher," custom job titles
- •Pet owners — Specific breeds with funny sayings
- •Hobbies — Fishing, crafting, gaming communities
- •Sarcastic humor — Office jokes, parenting quips
- •Zodiac/astrology — Birth month flowers, constellation designs
Average order value: Top mug designs sell 50-200 units/month
Pro tip: Mugs have lower individual margins but compensate with volume. One viral design can sell 100+ units monthly.
Canvas Prints
The Premium Margin Leader
Why they sell: High perceived value justifies premium pricing. Customers decorating homes invest more for quality wall art.
💰Profit Breakdown
🎯Winning Niches
- •Custom family prints — "Family Tree" with names, "Home is where [City]"
- •Motivational quotes — Minimalist typography
- •Pet portraits — Illustrated or photo-based
- •Botanical/nature — Scandinavian style, watercolor flowers
- •Abstract art — Geometric, minimalist, trendy color palettes
Average order value: $45-65 (12×16 to 16×20), $65-85 (18×24), $85-120 (24×36)
Pro tip: Offer 3-piece sets (triptych) for $150-200. Production cost ~$75-90, profit $60-110.
T-Shirts (Bella+Canvas 3001)
The Traffic Driver
Why they sell: Massive search volume ("custom t-shirt" gets 200K+ monthly searches). Lower margins but high velocity.
💰Profit Breakdown
🎯Winning Niches
- •Occupation humor — "I'm a [Job Title], What's Your Superpower?"
- •Pet breed specific — "Corgi Mom," "Beagle Dad"
- •Hobby communities — Crafters, hikers, gamers
- •Sarcastic sayings — Introvert humor, parenting jokes
- •Matching family sets — Higher AOV when selling 3-4 together
Average order value: $22-28 basic, $28-35 premium, $90-120 family sets
Pro tip: Use t-shirts as "gateway product" to build reviews. Once you have 50+ reviews, expand into higher-margin products.
Hoodies & Sweatshirts
The High-Margin Apparel
Why they sell: Higher price point = better profit margins. Strong Q4 seasonal demand but sells year-round in colder regions.
💰Profit Breakdown
🎯Winning Niches
- •Cozy aesthetic — "Coffee & Chill" vibes
- •Fandom references — Books, shows, games (avoid trademark violations)
- •College/Greek life — Custom sorority/fraternity designs
- •Matching couples/family — "Mr. & Mrs." sets
- •Seasonal — Christmas, fall/autumn themes
Average order value: $45-55 standard, $55-68 premium, $95-120 matching pair
Pro tip: List fall/winter designs in July-August. By November, you'll have reviews and algorithm traction for holiday rush.
The Printify Product Matrix: Margin vs. Volume
Strategic overview of all top products
| Product | Production | Retail | Profit/Unit | Volume | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stickers | $2-4 | $6-12 | $2-6 | Very High | Repeat customers, add-ons |
| Mugs | $8-12 | $18-28 | $5-12 | High | Traffic, reviews, volume |
| T-Shirts | $12-16 | $24-35 | $7-15 | High | Gateway product, reviews |
| Tote Bags | $10-14 | $22-32 | $6-14 | Medium | Eco-conscious, bundles |
| Throw Pillows | $16-20 | $35-55 | $12-28 | Medium-High | Home decor bestseller |
| Hoodies | $27-33 | $48-68 | $10-25 | Medium | Seasonal, higher margin |
| Canvas Prints | $22-38 | $55-95 | $20-45 | Medium | Premium margin |
| Blankets | $35-50 | $75-120 | $18-55 | Medium-Low | High-ticket, gifts |
| Phone Cases | $14-18 | $28-40 | $8-18 | Medium-Low | Niche personalization |
| Metal Prints | $30-60 | $85-180 | $20-95 | Low | Luxury positioning |
High Volume + Low Margin
Build reviews fast, steady cash flow
Low Volume + High Margin
Less fulfillment, premium positioning
Balanced Approach
Mix of both for sustainable growth
Choosing the Right Printify Print Provider
Printify connects you to 90+ print providers. Quality varies significantly.
Apparel (DTG)
Monster Digital (US)
Fast, consistent quality, Bella+Canvas blanks
SPOKE Custom Products (US)
Premium DTG, excellent color accuracy
District Photo (US)
Budget-friendly, good for testing
Home Decor
Fulfill Engine (US)
Pillows, blankets, excellent production time
Printify Express Delivery
Fast shipping, good for canvas
Creative Hub (Europe)
Quality home goods, lower shipping to EU
Mugs & Hard Goods
The Print Bar (US)
Reliable mug printing, fast turnaround
Fulfill Engine (US)
Consistent quality across mugs, phone cases
Duplium (Europe)
Good for international customers
Provider Selection Criteria
- 1.Production time: 2-4 business days ideal (avoid 7+ day providers)
- 2.Shipping speed: Domestic providers = faster delivery = happier customers
- 3.Price: Sometimes paying $1-2 more per item gets you 5-star quality
- 4.Reviews: Check Printify's provider ratings (aim for 4.5+ stars)
- 5.Location: US-based for US customers, EU-based for European buyers
Critical step: Order samples from 2-3 providers for each product. Compare quality, colors, packaging. Choose the best performer even if slightly more expensive.
Printify Success Timeline: What to Expect
Realistic expectations for your Printify journey
Foundation Building
- ✓ Publish 20-30 listings
- ✓ Order samples and photograph
- ✓ Test Etsy Ads ($5-10/day)
- ✓ Join relevant communities
- ✓ Share on social media
Traction Phase
- ✓ Double down on winning products
- ✓ Create variations of bestsellers
- ✓ Discontinue low performers
- ✓ Increase listings to 40-60
- ✓ Optimize underperforming titles/tags
Growth Phase
- ✓ Scale Etsy Ads on winners
- ✓ Expand product lines (complementary items)
- ✓ Build email list for repeat customers
- ✓ Improve product photography
- ✓ Raise prices on proven sellers
Scaling Phase
- ✓ Automate where possible
- ✓ Consider hiring VA for customer service
- ✓ Expand to complementary niches
- ✓ Launch seasonal collections early
- ✓ Build brand outside Etsy (social, email)
Important caveat: These are averages based on sellers who consistently optimize. Results vary based on niche, competition, design quality, and effort.
Common Printify Mistakes to Avoid
Learn from others' expensive mistakes
1. Choosing Products by Personal Preference
The problem: You love metal prints, but mugs sell 10x more volume
The fix: Lead with data, not feelings. Start with proven best sellers (pillows, mugs, tees), then expand to your preferred products once you have cash flow.
2. Ignoring Profit Margins
The problem: Selling t-shirts at $20 leaves $4-6 profit after Printify costs and fees. Not sustainable.
The fix: Calculate true profit before listing. If margin is <30%, either raise prices or choose different products.
3. Using Generic Designs
The problem: "Live Laugh Love" and "Coffee First" have 10,000 competitors
The fix: Niche down. "Coffee First, Teach Second, Wine Eventually" targets teachers specifically. Less competition, more connection.
4. Not Ordering Samples
The problem: Printify provider shows great mockups, delivers washed-out colors and poor print quality
The fix: Always order samples. Budget $100-150 to test 5-8 products from different providers before selling.
5. Listing Only 3-5 Products
The problem: Etsy's algorithm favors active shops. Low listing count = low visibility
The fix: Launch with minimum 15-20 listings. Add 3-5 new listings weekly to signal active shop.
6. Copying Competitor Designs Exactly
The problem: Copyright infringement, Etsy shop suspension, legal issues
The fix: Get inspired, but create original designs. Change colors, layout, wording, style. Make it your own.
Ready to Find the Exact Keywords Your Printify Products Should Target?
Use Insight Agent to analyze Etsy search volume, competition levels, and trending keywords in real-time.
Frequently Asked Questions
Everything you need to know about Printify on Etsy
This guide is based on comprehensive research and marketplace data as of February 2026. Profit margins, search volumes, and product performance are estimates based on industry analysis and may vary. Printify is an independent platform, and this content is not affiliated with or endorsed by Printify. This content is for informational purposes and not financial advice. Always conduct your own research before starting any business venture.
Start Your Printify Business on Etsy Today
Use InsightAgent's free tools to find profitable Printify niches, analyze successful shops, and optimize your listings for maximum sales.